The world view narrative of my life time has been Soviets, now Russians, bad, Americans good. The truth is much more nuanced and most importantly is that it’s not all Americans good and Russians bad, as Terry Cowan describes in a timeline that corresponds to a good chunk of my life.
I do know that Eisenhower warned about the wealth gathering of the military industrial complex that I cannot help but feel is behind much of what we do. I know that American involvement in Vietnam was not accepted to a majority of Americans. And I know that weapons of mass destruction was a false pretext to our invasion of Iraq. These don’t sum up to a trustworthy American side of the narrative.
Krugman, and all other pundits, need to get this through their head: there will not be another federal election in the U.S. in the manner we have come to expect. The sooner they figure this out and start saying it, the better. You don’t go through all the trouble of destroying things only to have someone else come along four years later to put it all back together. Threats to Trump and his guys that they will piss off voters are not threats.
Everything I see so far from the “press” and other media outlets seem to assume that upcoming elections are a threat to the Republican majority. All of these references appear to assume that future elections will be legitimate, but I think that assumption is dangerous. Do you think that neither Trump nor his supporters learned from 2020? For that matter, is Congress really relevant? If Democrats had a majority right now, would it matter?
I am afraid that we need to start talking more about liberty and what it actually means as it has been taken for granted and distorted to mean much. For me, agency such as described by Annie here in the section titled Radical responsibility, is fundamental to what I think is liberty.
Finished reading: Low Anthropology by David Zahl 📚
Anthropology is the study of humanity, in other words it is a study of us as humans. In this book the author suggests we tend to have a high view of ourselves, which he calls a high anthropology, whereas we would benefit from a more realistic view of ourselves that he calls low anthropology.
Yesterday and Monday we enjoyed a spring thaw that has turned to lower temps and some snow flurries. Ah, but yesterday was glorious.
Hello From Worldland
I wrote this post using Wordland, which is a new app developed by Dave Winer. It appears to focus on writing posts to Wordpress. Just made an edit, need to remember to push the post button. Like the little editing popup that appears when I select text.
The Republic Has Failed; Why Does It Matter?
Much of what I am seeing written about the state of the United States seems to be in the context of “Democracy is failing” or a “Constitutional Crisis” is imminent or present. The correct description of the United States as defined by the Constitution is a republic with self rule by a representative democracy.
The reality is that the republic, the one for which our flag stands (remember the pledge of allegiance) has failed. It failed when citizens and our representatives forgot or no longer valued the form of self government that has been in place. Our attitudes and inaction about the insurrection on January 6 is the clearest sign that the Republic has failed. Today we the citizens of the United States value power over liberty and our liberty exists to the extent it aligns to dictates of those in power.
Our conversations and writing on this topic need to transition to, why does it matter that the Republic has failed? The reality is, most people don’t think it matters because they have not yet recognized or acknowledged how their life has been impacted. Particularly Republicans and particularly those who support Trump.
My answer for why it matters is ironic. It matters because without the representative democracy of the Constitution the MAGA movement (or conservative movement) could not exist. Tyranny allows no opposition, thus had it been in place MAGA could not have done what it is currently doing. The Republic is what has allowed you to have your day, enjoy it but know that without it there will be no other opposition.
When the time comes that the “new” U.S. Government does something you do not like there will be nothing that you can do about it. The “elites” have determined Democracy is too inefficient and they think a more efficient government is controlled by a dictator, and they would be right. Freedom has been the purpose of the Republic, and inefficiency is a feature not a bug. However, the elites and their corporate/startup world view know what is best for them and have convinced you its better for you, and this will all work so long as you accept and comply with their dictates, their interpretation of current laws and their new laws.
Nadia Bolz-Weber, in a reply to questions from her readers about faith wrote:
I guess I just no longer think of faith as intellectually assenting to theological propositions, or as regularly confirming in myself that I believe all the wildest stories in the Bible are literally, factually, historically accurate. Faith functions in my life as something closer to gravity than ideology.
I like her description of faith as something closer to gravity than ideology.
Sitting in the living room, drinking coffee and doing my morning reading on this holiday while the winter wind howls in the background.